Discussions center on the difficulty of growing an email newsletter from zero, especially for self-published authors and solo creators. Members share both skeptical questions and aggressive growth experiments, from free-book magnets to newsletter swaps. A recurring theme is the disconnect between the '10k in 90 days' hype and the messy middle of small subscriber counts. The community is actively seeking realistic benchmarks, effective tactics, and ways to overcome platform and list-size constraints.
The audience includes self-published book authors (especially romance and fantasy), newsletter operators at various stages, and small entrepreneurs. Many have a following of a few hundred or are starting from zero; sophistication ranges from beginners to one operator with 200K subscribers. They are generally resourceful but feel overwhelmed by conflicting advice.
People try multiple tactics (Reddit, LinkedIn, swaps, ads) but cannot tell what drives subscribers versus what is noise. The lack of honest, actionable data makes growth feel like throwing darts in the dark.
“Every growth tactic I try feels like throwing darts in the dark and hoping one sticks.”
read the original thread →
“I post on Reddit and LinkedIn trying to funnel people in, some weeks I got 10 new subs, some weeks I get 2, and I can't figure out what actually moves the needle versus what's just noise.”
read the original thread →
“Every post online is either “I grew to 10k in 90 days” or “here are 12 tips” and nobody talks about what it actually feels like to be in the messy middle where the numbers are small and the doubt is loud.”
read the original thread →
Many creators have very few or zero subscribers after months of effort. They question whether their growth is normal-slow or bad-slow and wonder if it is even possible to grow from nothing.
“I have yet to have anyone sign up to my email list.”
read the original thread →
“I can't tell if 72 subs in 3 months is normal-slow or bad-slow.”
read the original thread →
To join bigger BookFunnel group promos and swaps, you need a minimum number of subscribers. This blocks beginners who have no list, making it hard to get the initial traction needed to qualify.
“a lot of the bigger promos want you to already have 500+ subscribers. Some I’ve seen want 1,500.”
read the original thread →
“Which is very “you need experience to get the job but you need the job to get experience” of them 😂”
read the original thread →
Creators find it hard to promote newsletters because platforms either ban self-promo, bury links, or are unavailable (like TikTok bans). This pushes them to seek alternative channels.
Sending frequent emails and swapping aggressively boosts numbers but also leads to high unsubscribe rates. There is tension between rapid growth and keeping engaged, loyal subscribers.
“It WILL annoy people. I have had a lot of unsubscribes.”
read the original thread →
“People didn't want it in their boxes that often and unsubscribed.”
read the original thread →
Creators cannot tell if slow growth means they picked the wrong topic or are executing poorly. This self-doubt is common and often persists for months.
“And I genuinely can't know if I picked the wrong angle, or if I'm just bad at this.”
read the original thread →
“I went through the same “is it my niche or am I just bad at this?” loop for months.”
read the original thread →
Creators without a large existing following feel stuck because many growth playbooks assume a built-in audience from Instagram, TikTok, or Twitter.
“Because I have no social media presence outside of Reddit and Discord”
read the original thread →
A/B testing tool for newsletter growth experiments
Addresses: Not knowing which growth tactics actually work
Industry benchmark reports showing normal growth rates by niche
Addresses: Starting from zero and slow growth is demoralizing
Curated directory of newsletter swaps with no minimum subscriber count
Addresses: Subscriber thresholds for newsletter swaps create a catch-22
Positioning newsletters as the one channel you fully own, independent of algorithm or platform bans
Addresses: Lack of social media following to bootstrap growth
Pre-made lead magnet templates for authors (exclusive chapters, bonus scenes, workbooks)
Addresses: Starting from zero and slow growth is demoralizing
Repurposing assistant that turns newsletter issues into platform-native discussion posts to avoid self-promo bans
Addresses: Self-promotion restrictions and platform bans