The community is centered on the struggle to market indie games in a saturated market. Developers discuss why marketing feels so hated and scary, and why social media posts, paid promotion, and Steam pages often fail to generate wishlists or sales. They are trying to find repeatable methods, realistic budgets, and ways to reach players without an existing audience. There is also frustration with contradictory advice and a community that complains about being ignored but rarely supports other devs.
Solo developers, hobbyists, full-time indies, and small teams, often technical/creative rather than marketing-trained. They have enough sophistication to discuss Steam CTR, wishlists, ROI, and Steam's 30% cut, but are overwhelmed by execution and lack a reliable system. Many work in isolation and express burnout.
Developers enjoy making games but dread marketing; it feels scary, unenjoyable, and exhausting, leading to burnout and resistance to even discussing it.
“It’s like doing taxes”
read the original thread →
“For me, as a hobbyist indie, I find promoting my games insanely scary.”
read the original thread →
“I know marketing is supposed to be a huge part of indie development, but honestly it’s the part I feel the most lost in and it makes me feel kinda burnt out.”
read the original thread →
Even experienced devs say their own marketing consistently fails and cannot find repeatable, reliable ways to get results beyond small social media likes.
“Hello! I have been a full time indie dev for a bit over 10 years now. One place that I always fail is marketing my own games before release.”
read the original thread →
“It seems like a fools errand trying to do your own marketing without any sort of big influence or outreach.”
read the original thread →
“Has anyone found any consistent, repeatable ways to get decent results marketing your own games? Something beyond the typical 20 likes on Twitter, something actually substantial and helpful.”
read the original thread →
Posts on X, Bluesky, TikTok and other networks get almost no traction; the engagement that does come is mainly from other developers, not potential players.
“But lately, it seems like no matter what I do, none of my posts are getting any traction in any social network (X, Bluesky, TikTok, etc.).”
read the original thread →
“On X, Bluesky, and TikTok I haven’t had much traction — most of the engagement comes from other devs, who probably won’t wishlist or be that interested anyway.”
read the original thread →
“I even paid for a month of X premium to improve visibility and asked Grok for some tips on how to use his own app to boost results, and after trying them... the results were even worse!”
read the original thread →
There is tension between making the game you love and choosing to make a marketable game; many devs skip research and benchmarking, assuming a good game will sell itself.
“some of them make really great games, with zero marketing, thinking that a "good" game will market itself.”
read the original thread →
“the others, would make the games they love with the hopes of making money, no research, no benchmarking or market analysis.”
read the original thread →
“For your game to sell, you need to make a good game, but before you make a good game, you need to choose to make a marketable game.”
read the original thread →
Developers see store page views and decent CTR, but the numbers do not turn into wishlists; months of effort can result in only a few dozen wishlists.
“In the beginning it was going well, my views was steady climbing, my steam page had good ctr but it doesn't convert to wishlist”
read the original thread →
“Devs who struggle for months to even reach a few dozen wishlists and start questioning if it's even worth continuing.”
read the original thread →
The community presents two extreme narratives — viral zero-budget success vs. total stagnation — leaving devs unsure whether success is luck or controllable marketing quality.
“I've been lurking here for weeks, following threads about indie game marketing, and I keep seeing two extreme narratives:”
read the original thread →
“I feel like there’s very little discussion about the middle ground – the realistic journey of an indie developer.”
read the original thread →
“Overall, I’m not exactly sure who to believe.”
read the original thread →
Paid marketing is seen as rarely worth it; devs worry about break-even and the math of paying streamers or ads against Steam's cut and low indie prices.
“Should you spend money on marketing for your indie game? The short answer: probably not.”
read the original thread →
“Sounds good, but most indie game campaigns don’t come close to that.”
read the original thread →
“Say you’re planning to release a game next year and want to boost your wishlists. You consider paying a streamer $50 to make a video about your game. Should you do it?”
read the original thread →
Indie devs say their games are ignored, yet they ignore other devs' work too; the community lacks mutual support and joy, making promotion feel even more thankless.
“Most solo devs complain their games are being ignored… but then they go and ignore everyone else’s work too. That’s just hypocritical.”
read the original thread →
“There’s a lack of joy in the community. Everyone complains when someone shares their game, but they still end up sharing their own... because we all *have* to. That kind of attitude? Just bad behavior.”
read the original thread →
“I recently started trying out other devs’ games, giving real, valuable feedback, wishlisting their projects (it costs me nothing), and supporting them however I can.”
read the original thread →
A launch-readiness marketing checklist that starts at concept and maps each development phase to concrete community-building and wishlist actions.
Addresses: No Repeatable Method; Wishlist Conversion Gap
A Steam page conversion diagnostic tool that tracks CTR, visit-to-wishlist conversion, and compares demo drop-off against genre benchmarks.
Addresses: Wishlist Conversion Gap
Rebrand self-promotion as 'finding the players who will love your game' and emphasize marketing as part of the creative process, not a chore.
Addresses: Marketing Aversion & Burnout
A break-even calculator and decision guide for paid marketing, tailored to indie game price points and Steam’s revenue split.
Addresses: Paid Marketing ROI Fear
A structured feedback/wishlist exchange program where devs support each other's launches, reducing indifference and isolation.
Addresses: Community Indifference
A non-social-media playbook covering press, streamers, Reddit, festivals, and demos with realistic expectations and timelines.
Addresses: Conflicting Advice & Luck Debate; No Traction on Social